I'm Sceptical About Counselling, But I Don't Know What Else to Do

← Back to blog

A lot of people who eventually book a counselling session aren't believers. They're not arriving convinced that talking to a stranger about their problems is going to fix anything. They're arriving because they've run out of other things to try, and someone, somewhere, suggested this might be worth a go.

If that's roughly where you are, you're in good company. It's a perfectly reasonable place to start from.

Being sceptical about counselling doesn't make you a bad fit for it. It might make you a more honest one.

Scepticism is not the obstacle people think it is

There's a common worry that doubting counselling means it won't work, or that you have to believe in therapy as a concept before it can do anything for you. That's not really how it works, at least not with person-centred counselling.

This approach doesn't ask you to believe in anything. It asks you to be willing to talk, honestly, in your own words, at your own pace. Belief isn't the entry requirement. Willingness is. And plenty of people who walked in doubtful still found something useful happened once they were actually in the room.

What the scepticism is usually about

Most scepticism about counselling comes from fairly specific worries, not a blanket dismissal of the whole idea. It's just talking, what difference can that actually make. I'll feel daft sitting there. What if they just sit there nodding and asking how that makes me feel. I don't want to be told what's wrong with me by someone who's known me for ten minutes. I've already tried to sort myself out and nothing's worked, so why would this be different.

Every one of those is a fair concern. None of them is unusual, and none of them means counselling isn't worth trying.

When scepticism turns into avoidance

Sometimes, though, scepticism is doing a slightly different job. It stops being a genuine reservation and starts being a reason not to go, a respectable-sounding cover for not wanting to be vulnerable in front of someone, or not wanting to find out what might come up once you actually start talking.

It's worth being honest with yourself about which one is happening. Healthy doubt and avoidance dressed up as doubt look very similar from the outside, but they tend to feel different once you sit with the question for a minute.

What actually happens

It's not advice-giving. It's not someone analysing you from a clinical distance and handing back a verdict. Person-centred counselling is a conversation, led entirely by you, at your pace, about whatever you actually want to talk about. There's no script, no checklist, and no pressure to arrive with the right words already worked out.

The free 20-minute consultation exists specifically for people in your position, sceptical, unsure, wanting to test the water before committing to anything. It's a low-stakes way to find out what it's actually like, rather than guessing.

You don't have to believe in it to try it

You don't need to arrive convinced. You just need to be willing to have one honest conversation and see what happens from there. That's a much smaller ask than most sceptics expect.

I offer person-centred counselling in Anfield, Liverpool and online across the UK. Sessions are £50, with reduced-fee spots available. There's a free 20-minute consultation with no pressure and no commitment.

Common questions

Is it normal to be sceptical about counselling?

Yes, very. A large number of people who eventually book a session start out doubtful, not as believers in therapy as a concept, but as people who've run out of other ideas and decided to try it anyway. Scepticism doesn't disqualify you from getting something out of it.

What if I don't believe therapy will work for me?

That's a reasonable place to start. Person-centred counselling doesn't require belief in the process to be useful, it requires willingness to show up and be honest. Plenty of people who didn't expect much from their first session found something useful happened anyway.

Do I have to believe in counselling for it to help?

No. Belief isn't a prerequisite. What tends to matter more is whether you can be honest in the room, even if you're also doubtful about the whole thing. The two can coexist perfectly well.

What if I don't know what's wrong, I just feel bad?

That's an entirely normal way to start. You don't need a diagnosis, a clear explanation, or even the right words before booking a first session. Most people arrive without having it figured out. Counselling is often where that gets worked out, not a prerequisite to entering the room.

How do I know if counselling is right for me?

A free 20-minute consultation is a useful way to find out without committing to anything. It's a chance to ask questions, get a feel for how the conversation goes, and decide afterwards whether it feels worth continuing, with no pressure either way.

You don't have to be convinced before you start

If any of this felt familiar, that recognition matters. I offer a free 20-minute conversation with no obligation and no pressure, just a chance to talk and see if working together feels right.

Book a Free 20-Minute Chat